Skip to content

Free tools / Stripe decline codes / fraudulent

Stripe fraudulent decline: what to do without accusing your customer

fraudulent means Stripe refused the payment because it identified it as potentially fraudulent. For a long-standing subscriber it may well be a false alarm, but the card should not be charged again as is.

Abderrahim Ben Jazia, PhDBy · Founder of FlowMRR, previously built and sold AIS (Avance Immédiate Services), French tax-credit softwareUpdated:
Decline code
fraudulent
Type
Blocked card
Who can fix it
The customer — needs to act
Will a retry help?
No: do not retry

What it means

Stripe flagged the payment as potentially fraudulent. Show the customer a generic decline, not this reason.

Lost, stolen, flagged or withdrawn. Do not retry: it can hurt your acceptance rate. Ask for a different card, through a neutral message.

Why it happens

  • Stripe's fraud screening scored the charge as risky, for example after unusual activity on the card or the account.
  • A change in the customer's pattern, such as a much larger amount after an upgrade.
  • Genuine misuse of the card, where the person who signed up is not the cardholder.

What to do

  1. Open the payment in Stripe and read its outcome and risk details to see what was flagged.
  2. Do not retry the same card, even if you believe it is a false positive.
  3. Contact the customer with a neutral message: the card could not be charged, please add another payment method. Never mention fraud.
  4. If the account looks suspicious (very recent, disputes on earlier charges), review it before restoring access.
  5. Once a different payment method is saved, collect the open invoice through the hosted invoice link.

Should you retry?

Do not retry. Stripe advises presenting this decline to the customer as a generic one, and repeated attempts on a card flagged for fraud can hurt your acceptance rate. Wait for the customer to add a different payment method.

What to tell the customer

Short and neutral, ready for a checkout error, a billing page or a support reply. No placeholders — ready to paste.

Your card was declined. Please pay with another card.

Customer email template

Neutral wording for this situation. Replace {name}, {product}, {link} and {company}.

Hi {name},

We were unable to process the payment for {product} with the card on file. Please get in touch so we can sort it out. If you would like to keep your subscription, you can add a different card here: {link}

Thanks,
{company}

Handling many failed payments? See how FlowMRR helps you prioritize failed Stripe payments by revenue at risk. Want a ranked list from your own account? Try the free failed payment audit.

Try FlowMRR free

Frequently asked questions

Is fraudulent the same as Radar's highest_risk_level?

Not quite. highest_risk_level is a Radar risk rating shown on payments Radar blocked itself; fraudulent is a decline_code. Both call for the same caution: no retries and a neutral request for another card.

My customer has paid for years. Is it really fraud?

Probably not. Fraud checks sometimes flag legitimate recurring charges. You still should not retry the same card: ask, without mentioning fraud, for another payment method.

What should my email to the customer say?

That the payment for their subscription could not be processed with the card on file, and that they can add another card through a link. No mention of fraud, risk or security checks.

Contact us
FlowMRR

Let's talk

A question, a technical issue or an idea for a partnership? Write to the FlowMRR team.